Discover the ultimate party hit: Fireball Jello Shots! These 4-ingredient wonders are quick, easy, and sure to be a crowd-pleaser. Indulge in the delectable taste of spicy cinnamon and elevate any adult gathering with this beloved favorite!
One of my favorite things to bring to any party are Jello shots. They are incredibly easy to make, and make a fun addition to any gathering! From making these incredible cherry cinnamon shots, to my vodka based Jello shots, and even fun Strawberry Pop Rock Jello Shots!
Why We Love this Fireball Jello Shots Recipe
- Easy to make– these tasty Jello shots call for only 4 ingredients and about 10 minutes to prepare!
- Incredibly Flavorful– a spicy cinnamon taste combined with sweet cherry Jello makes these the ultimate treat!
- Perfect for any party or gathering– not only do these travel well, but these bring everyone back to their younger years and are a fun way to celebrate any occasion!
Ingredients Needed for Fireball Jello Shots
See printable recipe card below for exact ingredient amounts and step by step directions.
- Cherry Jello– adds to the flavor and gives these their vibrant red color
- Boiling Water– this helps dissolve the Jello mix
- Cold Water– this helps the Jello to fully set up
- Fireball Whiskey– the boozy cinnamon whiskey addition to these shots
How to make Fireball Whiskey Shots
- In a bowl, combine the Jello and boiling water.
- Stir until dissolved.
- Add in the cold water and Fireball, stirring to incorporate.
- Pour the mix into 2 oz. plastic shot glasses until about ⅔ full.
Tips and Tricks for Success
- Be sure to keep your Jello Shots in the refrigerator until serving. This keeps them chilled and helps them stay fully set up.
- Have fun with these and feel free to garnish with whipped cream, cherries, Pop Rocks, Hot Tamale candy, or any other fun addition.
- Keep the shots covered in the refrigerator so they don’t develop a film on top. I use these plastic cups from Amazon and they work great!
- Allow these to fully chill. They will need a minimum of 2 hours to set up.
Variations
- Green Apple Jello in place of the Cherry Jello
- Orange Jello in place of the Cherry Jello
- Fun Garnishes such as whipped cream, Maraschino cherries, apple slices, candies, etc.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many Jello shots can I make using a small box of Jello?
If you use the 3.2 oz boxes of Jello, you should be able to get roughly 16 Jello shots. Of course, if you use the larger box of Jello (6 oz), you’ll be able to get about 32 Jello shots.
What is the best way to serve these Jello Shots?
There are so many different ways to enjoy these. Some like to enjoy them using mini spoons, others squeeze the cups into their mouth, or you can use your finger to loosen the edges of the Jello and it should pop right out.
How long do these last?
Not long in my house, BUT, if covered and stored in the refrigerator, they will last about one week. Unfortunately, they lose their flavor a bit after a few days, so try to enjoy them within about 3-4 days. I like to prepare these about 24 hours ahead of time to save on prep time.
What disposable cups are best to use for this recipe?
I prefer using 2 ounce plastic cups for this recipe. You can find the ones I use here. The great thing about these is they are inexpensive and come with lids making storing them and transporting them much easier. If you cannot find these cups, you can also use condiment cups.
How much alcohol can you put into Jello Shots?
Standard is to add ½ cup alcohol per 3 ounces Jello mix. If you want to add more for a stronger boozy taste, you can add up to an additional ¼ cup alcohol, however, anything past that will cause the shots to not fully set up and end up a liquid like mess.
Is a Jello shot the same amount as a regular shot?
Nope! Each of these Jello Shot cups have about ⅓ ounce of liquor in them. A classic shot (non Jello) has 1.5 ounces.
Can I make this jello shots recipe without the alcohol?
Absolutely! Simply omit the alcohol and use additional water! Another fun alternative would be to use apple juice or Sprite in place of the Fireball Whiskey.
More Party Drink Recipes to Try
Want to save this recipe?
Enter your email & I'll send it to your inbox. Plus, get great new recipes from me every week!
Fireball Jello Shots
Equipment
Ingredients
- 1 box Cherry or Orange Jello
- 1 cup Boiling Water
- ½ cup Cold Water
- ½ Cup Fireball
Instructions
- In a bowl, combine the Jello and boiling water.
- Stir until dissolved.
- Add in the cold water and Fireball, stirring to incorporate.
- Pour the mix into 2 oz. plastic shot glasses until about ⅔ full.
- Chill for 2 hours in the refrigerator. Serve and enjoy!
Nutrition
nicole says
if you dont want the jello to stick to the cup flip the cups upside down once they start to thicken.
Kristin says
Really?? I never knew this trick either! I will definitely be trying this and the Pam spray trick! Thanks!
Linda says
For the jello not to stick in the cup spray with Pam for cooking spray
Kristin says
I have heard this but never tried it! Do you taste the spray at all? That was my only hesitation to not trying that!
R pillow says
How do you get them not to stick
Kristin says
Typically, the method to remove the jello shot is to use your finger, go along the rim of the jello to loosen it and then take the “shot”. However, I have also heard you can spray a small amount of cooking spray into each cup prior to pouring the jello in. It should then pop right into your mouth. I haven’t tried it personally, but that should work!
Yolanda says
Would like to get ricips
Kristin says
Adding you to the mailing list right now! Welcome to the page and enjoy the recipes!
WWG says
Can you make it with 1 cup fireball and no cold water? For extra kick. Or, would they be gross or not set??
Kristin says
I like you’re thinking, however, if you increase the alcohol too much, it won’t set up. Bummer I know, but you’ll love these as is, I promise! Enjoy!
Kulsum Malek says
Can you make it without alcohol
Kristin says
Absolutely! Just prepare like you would normal Jello 🙂
mar says
How long will it stay out of the fridge
Kristin says
About an hour or so depending on temperature. Otherwise the jello will start getting a bit too liquidy
Jennifer says
What size jello?
Kristin says
The small package, I believe its 3 oz.
Emma Clark says
I used peach jello and it was super delish!
Kristin says
Ooooo, I will have to try that too! Thanks!
Tammy says
I’ve made them with green apple jolly rancher jello. Delicious, it’s a party favorite. Now I get requests to make them all the time.
Kristin says
Oooo yum, I will have to try that version too!!
DON DURHAM says
IF YOU DO IT THAT WAY THE ALCOHOL WILL EVAPORATE…
WAIT UNTIL IT IS COOL BEFORE ADDING THE FIREBALL.
Kristin says
Never knew that, thanks for that tip!!
Keith says
What about instead of a 1/2 cup of cold water, but use a 1/2 cup of cold cream soda? Taste like cinnamon rolls
Kristin says
That’s a great idea!! I think that would make these even better! Ill have to try that next time!!
Gwen Norris says
What do you think about using Strawberry. I don’t like Cherry and i can’t imagine making them with Orange flavor
Kristin says
That would work great as well! I have only tried cherry and orange, but strawberry should be just as yummy!
Heather says
How many did this recipe make?
Kristin says
This makes roughly 24 shots!!
Nadine says
Interesting .. I generally do a straight shot of fireball.. I’ll need to get some more next shopping trip.. Getting low
Kristin says
Yeah, same here, but now that I have tried these Jello Shots, I can’t imagine just plain Fireball anymore LOL